Bank of Cattaraugus Making a Difference Since 1882 Contact Us Address 24 Main Street, Cattaraugus,NY 14719 Phone 716.257.3431 Email support@bankofcattaraugus.com Fax 716.257.9116 Debit Card Self Service 1.800.472.3272 Activate New Card Report a lost/stolen debit card Credit Card Signup Apply Now Download Mobile Banking App